Fri 13 May 2005
I just ran across this article by Naomi Klein, written for The Nation:
Torture’s Dirty Secret: It Works
It gives us a terrible rationale for the use of torture that we seem to be overlooking in the United States. From what I have read and heard, torture does not work for intelligence gathering. But if people are aware that there is a possibility that they may be tortured, they can be effectively silenced and politically or socially demobilized.
If this is what is intended by torture, then we have a name for it. Terrorism. In this case, state-sponsored terrorism. One does not need explosions or loud bangs to terrorize a population.
Speaking of definitions… shortly after 9-11, I wrote an article in my college’s daily news paper, one of my biweekly columns for that semester. I bring up the article now, not so much because I discuss torture directly, but because the theme was the definition of “terrorism.” The writing/editing may not be pristine, and the ideas behind the words I am sure originated in greater minds than my own, but I felt proud to expose a wide audience to the concepts I was pushing. Here is the article (by the way, I did not come up with the title, must have been some editor too lazy to read it):
Ben’s post-911 article on terrorism
If you don’t want to read it, here’s the last line, which I really dig:
“Certainly steps should be taken to prevent terrorist acts similar to the ones we were recently forced to witness. But we must not let ‘Infinite Justice’ become an overzealous defense of the status quo that completely ignores our own role in world terror while silencing forms of legitimate dissent.”
May 14th, 2005 at 11:26 am
Very interesting. Problem is, pop culture has us believe torture does work. When Jack Bauer (of that awesome show 24) kicks the crap out of someone, they talk and the information provided is amazingly accurate. Then people at home think, “Hey, when Jack tortured that guy, he saved thousands of lives! Why not torture?”
May 18th, 2005 at 9:02 am
Finally, a website that I can agree with. Not only do I think torture does work but mental torture can be the worst form because the mind controls the body, so break the mind you break the body.
I am also doing a persuasive speech about how torture is truly better than the death penalty.
August 30th, 2006 at 6:47 pm
[…] And of course, check out other fine articles, such as: Luke’s article on the Newsweek Koran toilet story Melissa’s article on No Child Left Behind Ben’s thoughts on torture (including comments from a reader who clearly misunderstood the content) Luke’s article on ANWR Redder’s search for moderate Christians […]
February 13th, 2007 at 12:05 pm
I think torture is okay for informational purposes,but needs to humain
August 6th, 2007 at 10:52 am
Watch nude Paris Hilton sex tape clips…
Paris Hilton Sex Tape Criminal…