Wed 19 Jul 2006
A democracy worth fighting for?
Posted by MrKedder under Foreign Policy , Culture , State Terror , Civil LibertiesISRAEL!!!!!
It’s the name on the tip of everyone’s tongue, as it becomes the uncontrollable nation who’s lust for “security” ushers us into the third world war. In a stunning display of overcompensation, Israel has responded to the kidnapping of its soldiers with two lopsided revenge battleplans. The first is to continue to destroy the Palestinian infrastructure and thus deny a people of refugees any chance of a future. This is a cycle of behavior that has perpetuated itself for decades now. In response to a people that would stand up to the Jewish state and demand what is rightfully theirs, Israel says “Take that!” and simply blows up another school, or a manufacturing plant, or government offices. Advanced notice so as to allow for the evacuation of civilians is what passes for just and humane treatment by Israel. Never mind the fact that all citizens in the area are now left without a functioning school, or plant, or office. Now the same tactic will be applied in Lebanon for the same reasons, and an entire society will bear the brunt of Israel’s distemper.
As I check in at the Huffington Post, I see more and more castigation of my anti-war and anti-death stance, as it applies to Israel, being labeled outright anti-Semitism by one Alan Dershowitz. He makes his point in blogs like this one and this one, making it clear that to him, you’re either with Israel or against it. He even gets support in his hypocrisy from the United State’s UN Ambassador, John Bolton, who obviously thinks of Israelis as the new superior race. Wow, Alan, what a simple world you live in. How did you end up in such a stark realm of black and white? Because while Alan Dershowitz rants about policies like pre-emption and targeted killings being vital tools of democracy, Israel is continuing to exhibit some very un-democratic behavior. Imagine that, America’s Golden Child of the Middle East, the nation that is supposed to inspire the Arabs of the region to “embrace democracy”, well, it’s really not much better for freedom than Communist China. After all, by controlling what can and can’t be told, how exactly is Israel fostering the free and independent press that is the backbone of any free society or civilization?
I wish I wasn’t forced into a question of “Is Israel completely right or completely wrong?” by some of these pundits and opinionators. I absolutely respect a country’s right to safety for its citizens and peace of mind that an all-out assault by every power in the region isn’t going to occur at any minute. But those rights and securities come with the conditions that what you expect, you also exhibit, and what you put forth, returns upon you as well. So while Israel is bulldozing Palestinian houses, destroying offices and other facilities, and sending troops in to quell resistance, I can’t help but wonder how they can look at the international community with a straight face and say “We do this because we must, to protect ourselves.” My advice to Israel is that peace is best achieved through peace, not war. Perhaps if Israel sent construction workers and contractors into the Gaza Strip and West Bank instead of soldiers, tanks, and armed helicopters that shoot missiles at cars and houses with children in them, the response from the Palestinians might be a LOT different. In the meantime, until it stops showing signs of being like a kid who’s been bullied so much that he becomes a bully himself, I cannot and will not support Israel and it’s wars of vengeance. This is not a statement or post in favor of Hamas, or Hezbollah, or other Arab terror organizations instead of support for democracy. This is my post, about justice and accountability, and whether or not Israel is demonstrating enough of a commitment to true democracy and peaceful existence to warrant my support for it as a nation.
July 25th, 2006 at 10:47 am
I’m totally with you on how Israel should cool down. I hate war and death, but I’m not suprised Israel did this. Hezbollah keeps pulling crap like this (Hezbollah should be destroyed just for making the stupidest attack in terrorist history, hey, Palestine got bombed for kidnapping one soldier, let’s take two, that’s smart). I think Israel shouldn’t attack the infrastructure (like banks, wtf). Your right, It’s not “your with Israel, or against it” People who call people who dont completely agree with Israel 100% “anti-semetic” are just plain ignorant. The world isn’t black and white, but conservatives like to see it that way [they don’t like the black part
]. Good job man, please reply.
October 13th, 2006 at 1:19 am
Not because you’re so naively idealistic that you think the Palestinians will drop their rocket launchers and dance arm in arm with Israelis if they build them some houses. Not because you don’t realize that if Israel didn’t act like a bully it would be destroyed. Not even because you fail to acknowledge that militant Muslims don’t care about their own people any more than Israel does, and gladly kidnap Israeli soldiers in the hopes of goading Israel into killing their own wives and children. But because you actually think wartime censorship makes Israel “not much better for freedom than Communist China.”
Besides the fact that wartime censorship is very common, even for democracies, and China’s censorship is a permanent, peacetime endeavor, China is guilty of much more wrongdoing. Perhaps Israel’s actions would be more acceptable to you if they allowed Palestinians to become Israeli citizens before executing so many of them that they had to declare the exact number a “state secret” in order to avoid international embarrassment. And maybe it would be fine if those Palestinians were executed not because they were involved in terrorism, but for nonviolent crimes such as theft, embezzlement, bribery or credit card fraud. Of course there would be no point in calling them Muslims anyway, since they wouldn’t be allowed to openly practice their religion without fearing for their lives (unless it would be a profitable tourist draw, then it might be acceptable). But the families of those murdered Muslims could feel good knowing that their relatives’ organs were sold at high prices to save the lives of rich Europeans. And if a widow was worried about supporting her family she could adopt away her baby girl to an American with enough cash and take comfort in the fact that she wasn’t really allowed to have another child anyway (except for a second chance at a boy, if she was unlucky enough to have a girl the first time).
These examples are only a portion of the human rights abuses perpetrated on millions of Chinese every year. The irony of individual freedoms in China is that many of the things we consider “democratic,” such as the freedoms of press, speech, assembly, religion and the right to a fair trial are protected under the Chinese constitution, yet are restricted to the point of hypocrisy. So be careful the next time you feel the need to compare the Israelis to the Chinese or President Bush to Adolf Hitler. The result is not just ridiculous partisan diatribe, but a belittling of some of the worst atrocities in human history.
October 18th, 2006 at 10:52 am
That the Israelis were willing to concede territory shows the sincerity of their committment to peace with pride. It’s almost unheard of for a sovereign state to make such a concession freely to a sworn enemy in hopes of peace–especially when it has the power to annihilate the enemy with minimal damage.
Do you really think that the Israelis want this fight to keep going? And I might add that many of the Israelis who are hardline on this issue are Israeli Arabs who have no desire to live next door to Palestinian Arabs, their dysfunctional cultural relatives.
If Israel weren’t surrounded by sworn enemies that have demonstrated psychopathic feelings toward her, it wouldn’t be like this.
May 22nd, 2007 at 5:04 pm
Democracy is TRULY worth fighting for. If you have heard of the Tiananmen Square Massacre, I believe that the move of the Chinese students were truly amazing. I was inspired and noticed the strength students have in the world. These ppl were nearly teenagers! If you do believe DEMOCRACY is worth fighting for speak loud and clear!!!!!!!!!!!
September 18th, 2007 at 2:33 am
cams xxx…
A democracy worth fighting for?…
October 30th, 2007 at 11:06 am
how to calculate the winnings on a bet…
luxuriant exponentiate!Maya connectives:shit….
January 9th, 2008 at 1:05 pm
instant cash loans in baltimore…
arcades Wells.tediousness bedspread …